The Tan Turtle Tavern has such a large menu one wonders how they can possibly do it all well. Here are the results of our second visit.
Drink: TTT Black and Tan - Excellent!
Kid's Grilled Cheese - Excellent! Great bread.
Voodoo Fish Sandwich - Excellent! Great bun.
Chicken Pot Pie - So So. Very watery, soup-like "chicken stew". Menu claimed 'seasonal veggies' but the reality its was frozen peas and carrots.
We like the place, it's just a matter of figuring out what they do well (any fish dish seems like a safe bet) and what to avoid.